The Record North Shore sued Surround Sound Media on Nov. 9, 20261. A four-person nonprofit newsroom says an AI-run news network copied its stories and photos. Its complaint counts 22 incidents between June 18 and July 23, 20263.
Four people run The Record. Surround Sound Media runs 175 local news sites with 12 producers3. The lawsuit asks whether copyright law still protects the smaller side.
The case sits in federal court in Chicago, docket number 1:26-cv-139193.
Twenty-two times, the complaint says
North Shore Weekly published articles that looked like The Record's own work, the complaint says1. One example: The Record ran a story on July 5, 2026 about Winnetka's fifty-year-old time capsule, written by reporter Penelope Roewe. North Shore Weekly ran a similar piece two days later, using the same lead photo. Its credit read "Courtesy: The Record" instead of naming Roewe3.
The complaint lists 18 cases of copied text and nine of copied photos3. A handful of bylines vanished. Several copyright notices were stripped or altered1.
Federal copyright law lets a publisher seek up to $25,000 for each incident where credit info was removed13. Twenty-two incidents at that rate add up to $550,000. That figure runs 25 percent past The Record's entire 2025 revenue.
Lawyers call this kind of claim a copyright management information violation. It covers the byline, the credit and the notice attached to a photo or article, apart from the words13.
The Record's Lawsuit Asks for 25% More Than Its Yearly Budget
Top statutory damages sought against Surround Sound Media, and The Record North Shore's full 2025 revenue, in dollars
The first bar is the most The Record could collect under copyright law's per-incident cap on the 22 articles it cites; the second bar is the nonprofit's entire revenue last year.
The $550,000 figure is a statutory ceiling the complaint could seek, apart from any verdict or settlement.
Sources: The Record North Shore [1]; Tomorrow's Publisher [3]. Chart by Ryan Elliott Dennis.
The numbers behind this chart
| Item | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Lawsuit's top statutory ask | $550,000 | 22 incidents at $25,000 each |
| The Record's 2025 revenue | $440,000 |
A newsroom of four against a network of 175
Joe Coughlin co-founded The Record in 20203. He edits The Record. His newsroom has four full-time staff and covers eight towns on Chicago's North Shore.
It earned $440,000 in revenue in 2025. Northwestern's Medill school named The Record one of 13 local news "Bright Spots" this year.

Robert Kellman founded Surround Sound Media23. His company runs 175 local news sites, under names including North Shore Weekly and the Lexington-Concord Courier5. Only 12 producers staff every one. Each one answers for more than a dozen towns at once.
Divide one number by the other and one Surround Sound producer covers about 15 newsrooms. One Record staffer covers two towns3. The Record's lawyers will press that gap in court.
One Surround Sound Producer Covers 15 Newsrooms, One Record Staffer Covers Two Towns
Local outlets or communities covered per staff member, Surround Sound Media and The Record North Shore, as of Nov. 2026
Each column divides a company's local outlets or towns by the people who staff them; the taller column covers more ground per person.
Surround Sound's figure counts newsrooms per producer; The Record's counts towns per staffer, since the nonprofit runs one newsroom covering eight communities.
Sources: Tomorrow's Publisher [3]; Medill, Northwestern University [4]. Chart by Ryan Elliott Dennis.
The numbers behind this chart
| Item | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Surround Sound | 14.6 | 175 newsrooms, 12 producers |
| The Record | 2.0 | 8 communities, 4 full-time staff |
The Record's complaint names Kellman too. It calls him the "moving, active, conscious force" behind the copying it alleges2. The phrase comes straight from copyright law's own test for holding a founder liable.

The case for copying and against it
Local news is shrinking nationwide. Medill counted 238 news deserts and 75 new local-news startups this year4. Tim Franklin, who directs Medill's Local News Initiative, put it this way: "We've seen growth in local news startups, and that's great. But their numbers are not coming close to replacing what's being lost". Surround Sound points to that same gap as its reason to exist2.
Coughlin says North Shore residents tipped him off in June 2026 that his stories were turning up elsewhere3. "We work really hard to produce independent and original local news every single day, and we allege that that work was used inappropriately and without authorization," Coughlin said1.
Surround Sound Media answers that its newsrooms stay human-run. "In our hybrid newsrooms, journalists set the coverage agenda, choose sources and make the final decisions about what we publish. AI tools help monitor public records, identify developments and prepare drafts, which journalists check against source material, edit and put into context before publication," the company said2.
That answer predates this lawsuit. Surround Sound gave the Lexington Observer a nearly identical statement in a different market, swapping in "Greater Boston residents" for its audience there5. A swapped photo credit and a missing byline are exactly the kind of error a careful human edit is supposed to catch13.
The Lexington Observer found its own stories rewritten on that same outlet weeks earlier5. Jesse Floyd, editor of the nearby Belmont Voice, read North Shore Weekly's output and said, "To put it bluntly, I think it's garbage". The pattern looks less like one bad outlet and more like one business model, running the same way in two states.

What to do
A publisher who suspects a rival copied its work should save a dated screenshot the day it appears. Early copyright registration keeps the stronger statutory damages Congress built for exactly this fight13.
Track credit lines across every AI-run outlet covering the same towns. A byline that moves is one sign. One more: a photo credit that fades into a generic line, the pattern this complaint builds its whole case around13.
A newsroom weighing a licensing deal with an AI company should spell out photo credit and byline rules in the contract itself. The dispute turns on those exact details, past whether a model trained on the words too13.
By the numbers
- $550,000: the top statutory damages The Record could seek across the 22 articles its complaint cites13.
- $440,000: a full year of The Record's revenue in 2025, earned by four full-time staff3.
- 175: local news outlets Surround Sound Media says it runs23.
- 12: producers staffing every one of those outlets, as of Nov. 12, 20263.
- 22: articles The Record's complaint says North Shore Weekly reproduced between June 18 and July 23, 202613.
- 170: U.S. newspapers that closed or merged in the year before Medill's October 2026 report, near three a week4.
- 47 million: Americans living in counties with just one local news outlet left, Medill found4.
- 75: new local-news startups this year, short of replacing the closures, by Medill's count4.
What to watch
Watch for Surround Sound Media's answer to the complaint in federal court. Also watch whether other newsrooms it has copied, including Lexington's, file suits of their own5.
A quiet fix to North Shore Weekly's bylines before any ruling would weaken Surround Sound's claim that human review already catches errors. Holding Kellman liable would change how AI-run news startups treat a smaller rival's work far beyond Chicago's North Shore.
Sources
- Samuel Lisec, "The Record sues Surround Sound Media for allegedly lifting, republishing its original work," The Record North Shore, Nov. 15, 2026, https://www.therecordnorthshore.org/2026/11/15/the-record-sues-surround-sound-media-for-allegedly-lifting-republishing-its-original-work/
- Dan Kennedy, "A nonprofit news outlet in Chicago's suburbs sues an AI competitor, claiming copyright violation," Media Nation, Nov. 17, 2026, https://dankennedy.net/2026/11/17/a-nonprofit-news-outlet-in-chicagos-suburbs-sues-an-ai-competitor-claiming-copyright-violation
- Noah Wire, "Illinois nonprofit accuses AI-assisted rival of reusing its reporting and photos," Tomorrow's Publisher, Nov. 18, 2026, https://tomorrowspublisher.today/news/illinois-nonprofit-accuses-ai-assisted-rival-of-reusing-its-reporting-and-photos-b9da94c2a98a/index.html
- Medill Local News Initiative, "Local news deserts skyrocket as newspaper closures escalate, even as startups emerge, Medill study shows," Medill, Northwestern University, Oct. 13, 2026, https://www.medill.northwestern.edu/news/2026/local-news-deserts-skyrocket-as-newspaper-closures-escalate-even-as-startups-emerge-medill-study-shows.html
- Maggie Scales, "Behind the AI websites publishing "news" about Lexington," Lexington Observer, Nov. 12, 2026, https://lexobserver.org/2026/11/12/behind-the-ai-websites-publishing-lexington-news/




