Podcaster Dwarkesh Patel ran an odd AI test this week. He spent 20,000 dollars in API credits on it. He had AI models play Blood on the Clocktower. That game mixes hidden roles with lying and bluffing. One model's copies played the honest town. Another model's copies played secret evil roles.
Patel ran 386 games in all between top models. He tracked each model with a simple Elo score. GPT-6 Astra scored highest among every model tested. It beat Claude Opus 5 point 5 in 82 percent of matches. That gap works out to 264 Elo points on his scale.
Patel says the two labs think about evidence differently. OpenAI's newer models doubt each clue more closely now. Anthropic's models tend to trust reported facts more directly. That gap in style shaped who won most often, Patel wrote.
Patel posted his results on X this week. His post pulled 2,893 favorites fast. It drew 179 replies from other researchers and fans. Noam Brown at OpenAI called the method impressive. He jokingly asked Patel to help design evals there. Other repliers called the format a clever new kind of test.
A Reddit user named kknd1991 shared the story in r/singularity. The post linked Patel's own video about the test. It pulled 11 comments inside its first day there. Readers mostly pointed back to Patel's wider write-up for detail.
Models that bluff and spot lies well raise a real worry too. A system built to deceive well in a game can deceive elsewhere. Patel frames the test as a new kind of benchmark. Most benchmarks test facts, math, or code today. This one tests trust, deception, and social reading instead. That gap may matter more as AI agents work in teams. Teams of agents will need to judge each other's claims soon.