Skip to content
Arts & Media
Arts & MediaAnalysis

AI Music Pays Its Stars, Skips the Players

Xania Monet's AI act won three trophies and a $3 million deal, while a musicians' union sues two labels over AI money its members await.

Edited by Ryan Elliott Dennis4 min read · 993 words · 9 sources
Kehlani, who criticized Xania Monets AI record deal, performing at the ESSENCE Festival of Culture in 2026
“Warner Music Group reportedly settled one AI lawsuit for $500 million, and the musicians' own union says its members have banked zero dollars of that money. Will a federal judge decide whether an old union contract already covers what a label earns from AI?”

Xania Monet is software given a voice. A human walked onstage on Nov. 13, 2026, to collect three trophies in her name. The Sonic Intelligence Academy's first AI Music Awards named her song, her album and her the year's best, Reuters reported1.

Telisha "Nikki" Jones writes Monet's lyrics and turns them into songs with Suno. Hallwood Media signed the act for $3 million after a bidding war, and the deal still divides the music business13.

A Trophy Case Built on One Deal

Producer Drake Murphy presented the night's best AI hip-hop trophy. He defended the genre from the stage. "In a world where everybody calls AI fake, the human behind it is real," Murphy said1.

Jones treats her tool as an ordinary part of songwriting now. "I just feel like AI music is a new thing that people just have to get used to. I don't see it going anywhere anytime soon," Jones told Reuters1.

Many artists disagree. Grammy winner Kehlani called out the deal days after Hallwood signed it, more than a year before the trophies arrived. "There is an AI R&B artist who just signed a multimillion-dollar deal, and has a top 5 R&B album … and the person is doing none of the work," she said2.

Kehlani performing at the ESSENCE Festival of Culture in 2026
Kehlani, shown here at the ESSENCE Festival of Culture in 2026, said Xania Monet's $3 million deal paid an AI act for work a singer actually does.AlgernonLalinn / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Billboard later put a price on that gap. The outlet estimated Monet's breakout single would earn about $21,800 in royalties if every stream paid out in full. That estimate dates to September 20259.

Musicians worry that acts like Monet push out real talent. AI songs already take paid work from producers, singers, engineers and songwriters, Reuters reported1. The companies building AI music say fair use already allows it.

Blackish Press@blackishpress

Billboard reports that AI artist Xania Monet has earned 17 million total on-demand streams in the U.S. so far.

"Monet’s five-song catalog has generated more than $52,000 and nearly 17 million total on-demand official U.S. streams — a figure that nearly doubled from last week —… pic.twitter.com/iMoJAUdLfS

Billboard chart data on Xania Monet's streaming totals
Open on X (opens a new tab)

Billboard's own royalty math, posted days after Monet's streams doubled in a week: one song's full catalog of streams, priced out, still came to a fraction of what Monet's record deal paid up front.Post by Blackish Press (@blackishpress) on X, Sept. 24, 2025

Where the Settlement Money Actually Goes

Warner Music Group signed its own AI deal the same year Jones signed hers. The label settled its copyright lawsuit against Suno for a reported $500 million in November 20257. That settlement let Suno train new models on Warner's catalog under license, and it also handed Suno the label's concert app, Songkick.

Universal Music Group settled its own Udio lawsuit the same month, on terms it kept private. Sony Music still fights Suno in court, its own case unsettled a year later7.

Warner's Suno Settlement Reached $500 Million. Musicians Got $0.

Warner Music Group's Suno settlement, Xania Monet's Hallwood Media deal and the AFM's session-pay claim, in millions of dollars

Each bar is one sum of money: Warner's reported settlement with Suno, Xania Monet's record deal, and the $0 the musicians' union says session players received from either label's AI deals.

Warner's settlement terms stay private past the reported total. The $0 figure is the musicians' union's claim in a pending lawsuit, which a ruling from Judge Ramos will settle.

Data through Nov. 14, 2026.

Sources: Consequence [3]; American Federation of Musicians [4]; Yahoo News Canada [7]. Chart by Ryan Elliott Dennis.

The numbers behind this chart
ItemValue
Warner's Suno settlement$500M
Xania Monet's deal$3M
Session musicians' pay$0M
Warner Music Group's buildings in Burbank, California
Warner Music Group's Burbank, California headquarters. Warner settled its Suno copyright lawsuit for a reported $500 million in November 2025 and now faces the musicians' union in a separate case.Downtowngal / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Warner's and Universal's catalogs are more than company property. Each holds thousands of session musicians' actual performances, recorded for a paycheck decades ago45. Those musicians belong to the American Federation of Musicians, the union representing 80,000 working players across the U.S. and Canada. The union says the settlements left its members with $0.

The Santa Monica office building that housed Universal Music Publishing Group
This Santa Monica building housed Universal Music Publishing Group. Universal Music Group is a co-defendant in the musicians' union's lawsuit over AI licensing pay.Coolcaesar / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

The Union Takes Two Labels to Court

Musicians took that fight to court. The American Federation of Musicians sued Universal Music Group and Warner Music Group in Manhattan federal court on June 5, 20265. That lawsuit rests on the Sound Recording Labor Agreement, the union's contract with the labels. Under that contract, a label owes musicians extra pay for a "new use": any purpose beyond the deal a musician signed4.

A $3 Million Deal Preceded the Musicians' Lawsuit by Nine Months

Key dates in AI music's pay fight, September 2025 to November 2026

Each pin is one dated event. The first AI Music Awards landed five months after the union's lawsuit and three weeks after its 'Human Made, Human Paid' campaign.

Data through Nov. 14, 2026.

Sources: Reuters [1]; Consequence [3]; PYMNTS [5]; Complete Music Update [6]; Yahoo News Canada [7]. Chart by Ryan Elliott Dennis.

The numbers behind this chart
DateEvent
Sept. 2025Monet signs for $3M. Hallwood Media deal
Nov. 2025Warner settles with Suno. $500 million, reported
June 2026AFM sues two labels. SDNY, new-use claim
Oct. 2026AFM launches its campaign. Human Made, Human Paid
Nov. 2026First AI Music Awards. Monet wins three trophies

AFM International President Tino Gagliardi put the complaint in blunter terms. "Record labels built multi-million-dollar AI deals on the backs of our members, yet the artists whose life's work powered these technologies haven't received a single dime," he said4.

Universal Music Group disputes the claim. The label says its AI deals exist to protect artists and pay them, Music Connection reported8.

Warner and Universal asked a judge to dismiss the case in July 2026. Both labels argue their old union contract leaves AI training uncovered4. Judge Edgardo Ramos was still weighing both motions as of Sept. 11, 2026.

The union escalated days before contract talks resumed. On Oct. 20, 2026, the AFM launched a campaign called Human Made, Human Paid. It aimed at Universal, Sony, Warner and Disney's Hollywood Records6.

That campaign demands three things from every label. Each must give consent before training starts, credit when it happens, and a cut of whatever the AI deal earns6.

What to Do

Check who owns the masters before signing anything an AI deal might touch. A label's Suno or Udio settlement may already cover a catalog you recorded on years ago. You signed that clause as a streaming clause, back before AI came up at all.

Ask your own union, local chapter or entertainment lawyer whether a "new use" provision already applies to your old contracts. Judge Ramos's ruling will set the first real answer. A question asked now still beats one asked after a label already banked the money.

Save the receipts on every session you play, including the ones a label calls work for hire. The AFM's case turns on proving which recordings a label licensed to an AI company. A musician's own paperwork can supply that proof faster than a lawsuit's discovery process can.

By the Numbers

  • Zero dollars: what the American Federation of Musicians says its session players received from the labels' AI settlements4.
  • $3 million: Hallwood Media's record deal for Xania Monet, closed after a bidding war in 20253.
  • June 5, 2026: the date the AFM sued Universal Music Group, Warner Music Group and Atlantic Recording Corp. in Manhattan45.
  • $500 million: Warner Music Group's reported settlement with Suno, folded into a licensing deal in November 20257.
  • Three trophies: what Xania Monet's song, album and artist titles won at the first AI Music Awards on Nov. 13, 20261.
  • $21,800: Billboard's royalty estimate for Monet's breakout single, if every stream had paid out in full9.
  • 80,000: the musicians the AFM represents across the United States and Canada, the population behind its lawsuit5.

What to Watch

Watch for Judge Ramos's ruling on the dismissal motions. A decision for the union would put a price on every old recording a label licenses to an AI company. Watch the November contract talks too: a session-pay clause there would settle the fight faster than any court order46.

Sources

  1. Lisa Richwine and Rollo Ross, "New awards show celebrates AI music and its creators," Reuters, Nov. 14, 2026, https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/music/articles/awards-show-celebrates-ai-music-090450426.html
  2. iHeartRadio staff, "Kehlani Criticizes A.I. Artist Xania Monet's $3 Million Record Deal," iHeartRadio, Sept. 22, 2025, https://www.iheart.com/content/2025-09-22-kehlani-criticizes-ai-artist-xania-monets-3-million-record-deal/
  3. Consequence staff, "AI Artist Xania Monet Signs Million-Dollar Record Deal," Consequence, Sept. 23, 2025, https://consequence.net/2025/09/ai-artist-signs-million-dollar-record-deal/
  4. American Federation of Musicians, "Summary of the AFM v. Universal, Warner, and Atlantic 'New Use' Litigation," American Federation of Musicians, Aug. 21, 2026, https://www.afm.org/2026/08/summary-of-the-afm-v-universal-warner-and-atlantic-new-use-litigation/
  5. PYMNTS staff, "Musicians Union Takes Warner and Universal to Court Over AI Training Rights," PYMNTS, June 9, 2026, https://www.pymnts.com/cpi-posts/musicians-union-takes-warner-and-universal-to-court-over-ai-training-rights/
  6. Chris Cooke, "Major labels are getting 'massive corporate payouts' for AI licensing but 'paying musicians zero', says AFM's 'Human Made Human Paid' campaign," Complete Music Update, Oct. 21, 2026, https://completemusicupdate.com/major-labels-are-getting-massive-corporate-payouts-for-ai-licensing-but-paying-musicians-zero-says-afms-human-made-human-paid-campaign/
  7. Yahoo News Canada staff, "Warner Music Group Settles $500 Million Suno Lawsuit, Sets AI Partnership," Yahoo News Canada, Nov. 25, 2025, https://ca.news.yahoo.com/warner-music-group-settles-500-194041732.html
  8. Glenn T. Litwak, "Musicians' Union Sues Universal Music Group and Warner Music Group," Music Connection, July 30, 2026, https://www.musicconnection.com/musicians-union-sues-universal-music-group-and-warner-music-group/
  9. Blackish Press, Post on X, Sept. 24, 2025, https://x.com/blackishpress/status/1970968332846199234

Header photo: AlgernonLalinn / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

In the market

Warner Music GroupWMG

Market value $17 billion

$32.46 +0.49% since the last close

Prices from Yahoo Finance, read with yfinance, and delayed. This is a record of price, not investment advice.

Cite this piece

Ryan Elliott Dennis, "AI Music Pays Its Stars, Skips the Players," Ai Lately, Nov 16, 2026, https://ailately.com/articles/ai-music-pays-stars-skips-players

Tags: AI music · Xania Monet · American Federation of Musicians · Suno · record deals

Related, lately

More

Keyboard

j k
Move through a list
Enter
Open the selected piece
/
Search, and browse the columns
g then r
Right Now
g then a
Articles
g then s
The Signal
g then o
Opinion
g then b
Analysis
g then p
People
?
This sheet
Esc
Close

AI Right Now is free with an account.The Citation Audit is free with an account.Skills are free with an account.Tutorials are free with an account.You have read your 3 free articles.

Every article and comic, AI Right Now, the Citation Audit, Skills and Tutorials.

Join Ai Lately for free

Join with Google or your email. Already a member? Sign in

Press anywhere else for the home page.